Gary Gutting Replies to Dawkins in the New York Times

Here.

FWIW: I think apologists occasionally make things easy on themselves by focusing on Dawkins' philosophical criticisms of theism (for the real thing, read Wielenberg's paper). For example, I think his stuff on the prima facie immoral character of the God Yahweh, as depicted in the Old Testament (e.g., divinely-mandated genocide, etc.) isn't half bad.