Thanks, Ex. Unfortunately, Ward's review is full of subtle and not-so-subtle misstatements of my views. And he omits even to mention some of my central moves. I guess I'll now have to correct the record. It would be nice if NDPR ran reviews by authors before publishing to avoid this sort of thing, as the journal Mind does.
2 comments:
From J.L. Schellenberg
Thanks, Ex. Unfortunately, Ward's review is full of subtle and not-so-subtle misstatements of my views. And he omits even to mention some of my central moves. I guess I'll now have to correct the record. It would be nice if NDPR ran reviews by authors before publishing to avoid this sort of thing, as the journal Mind does.
Interesting. I suspected some of Ward's review was moderately off in regards to Schellenberg's views.
Post a Comment