Graham's New Critique of Plantinga's Argument from Proper Function

Peter Graham recently offered an excellent critique of Plantinga's argument from proper function in his "Intelligent Design and Selective History: Two Sources of Purpose and Plan" (in Jonathan Kvanvig, ed. Oxford Studies in Philosophy of Religion, Volume 3, 2011).

(On previous occasions, we've noted critiques of the argument from Adrian Bardon and Tyler Wunder).

No comments:

Important Recent Work on Theodicy

Hill, Scott. " Why God Allows Undeserved Horrendous Evil ", Religious Studies (Online First 28 Sept. 2021). In the paper, Hill ap...